Reply: 1Author: jawapro
Date: Fri 11/07/2008 12:08 PM
I actually liked all of them, in their own way.
Doctor 6 (Colin Baker) was my least favorite - but I didnt actually hate him like many people.
I didnt see much of number 2 (Patrick Troughton) either.
The first doctor was old and sometimes rather crabby - but pretty cool.
The third doctor was awesome. Stuck on Earth for a while - but a great doctor.
Doctor number 4 was Tom Baker - and most people's favorite. Not hard to see why, he was brilliant too.
Doctor number 5 was Tristan... umm sorry, Peter Davidson. I really liked him too.
The three 3,4,5 are the best of the old series.
Colin Baker (6) was grumpy - and not so much fun to watch.
Silvester McCoy (7) would have been a decent doctor - but was stuck with really really lame stories.
The doctor from the movie (8) was actually really good. It was the only good thing in the movie though - which sucked big time.
Chris Eccelston (9) was the first of the new doctors and wasnt bad. He did have a dark edge which I liked - but then fell in love with Rose, which I didnt.
The 10th doctor (David Tenant) is brilliant. I especially like it when he goes dark (end of Family of Blood etc). Suffers due to the fact that most of his stories were helmed by RTD.
So its sort of a toss up between 3,4,5, and 10 for me.
So I'll just go and say that the best Whovian story ever is an audio series called Dalek Empire - and the Doctor is not even in it. So I'll vote for Karlendorf instead....
Maelstrom Fansite
